Pandemic Pushes Design Rethink

Queuing and traffic pattern adaptations may reflect a more permanent change in the consumer shopping experience.

Pandemic Pushes Design Rethink

December 2020   minute read

By:Renee Pas

Commonplace elements now in c-stores include hand sanitizers readily available for customers and staff, floor markers to maintain social distancing, masks for all and some kind of protective barrier shielding staff and customers from each other. These could largely be argued as the new norm in standard operating procedures more than a shift in store design, but they are certainly a marked change in the c-store shopping experience. Whether or not they will be permanent components of a c-store remains an unanswered question, but most expect they will stick around at least until a COVID-19 vaccine permeates through the U.S.

What’s happened to date are adaptations, said Steve Montgomery, president of b2b Solutions LLC, a c-store consultant group based in Lake Forest, Illinois. Some of those adaptations may not remain over the long term, but he feels what will stick around is building stores with “what if” in mind. “The pandemic accelerated the process of what was already happening,” he noted, making conversations about how to execute contactless payments and experiences or adding a drive-thru all the more pressing.

Designing Around the Queue

Industry observers agree that the pandemic accelerated a lot of things for the c-store industry. “Instead of plan, test and act, chains are going straight to act,” said Ed Burcher, a consultant with Business Accelerator Team based in Phoenix. He identified the forced queue as one component nearly everyone has put into action with floor markings, although the strategy behind a great customer checkout line goes deeper than that. Even without social distancing mandates, he said, “Forced queuing is a logical and brilliant way to force people through a store.”

Forced queuing is a logical and brilliant way to force people through a store.

While it can take time and new builds to incorporate larger structural changes, such as separating primary entrances and exits into a design, Burcher noted that many chains are already doing just that or were making strides before the pandemic in newer stores. He points to Speedway and Wawa as two examples already embracing new queuing philosophies. “It’s about guiding people through the store the way the operator wants,” he said.

Another store worth looking at for best practices in customer flow is QuikTrip, said Nathan Underhill, president of iSEE Store Innovations, a design and manufacturing company based in St. Louis, Missouri. One of the things that he sees as a strength at QuikTrip is the chain’s precisely marked checkouts. “It’s clear where you are supposed to be,” he said.

“We were already seeing the importance of queuing grow; the current situation is bringing a lot of things that were already in motion and expediting them,” Underhill said. “Customers don’t want to think about anything or touch anything. Retailers are adapting to that and showing wayfinding and subtle cues.”

Queue management is a mix of art and science, said Perry Kulkin, director of marketing for Lavi Industries, a queue management solutions provider and manufacturer based in Valencia, California. “Queuing at checkout is one of the last things businesses think about,” he admitted, well, at least pre-pandemic. As crowding happens and customer flow issues become more apparent, there is a greater need to manage that flow of people to avoid groups of people congregating—something that was never a good approach, he noted.

We have seen even small operators switch to single-line queues to better manage flow.

“When it comes to the pandemic, a single-line queue is probably the safest way to execute things,” Kulkin said. It not only keeps people organized, but it can create impulse opportunities as people go through that queue, he added. A typical strategy starts with the head of the queue being well marked with signage and fixtures. Since people can generally find that easily, it creates a natural starting point. Merchandising fixtures can help extend the flow, he said.

“In the last six months we have seen even small operators switch to single-line queues to better manage flow,” Kulkin said. “The last thing they want is to give the impression that it’s a free-for-all inside. The pandemic forced people to look at how they are dealing with the customer flow inside and out of their store.”

In and Out Safely

Speed of transaction and customers’ ease to find what they want also is amplified today, added Joseph Vonder Haar, CEO/partner of iSEE Store Innovations and former chairman of the NACS Supplier Board. He explained it this way: People want to get in, touch as few items as possible while finding what they want and get out. “Speed of transaction is more important than ever because it connects to safety now.” To support the goal of touching fewer things, iSEE is vetting a new product that can open cold vault doors without requiring customers to use their hands.

“It’s about a contactless experience,” said Vonder Haar, who believes consumers now extend that notion to curbside pickup. In fact, many c-store designers concur that curbside pickup, as well as drive-thrus, may significantly change the design of c-stores down the road.

While by no means a c-store mainstay, c-store chains were testing—or already executing—curbside pickup prior to the pandemic. The bulk of those chains are, no surprise, well-known names: Casey’s, Kum & Go and Wawa among them. However, even lesser-known operators can find success with contactless options such as curbside, delivery and drive-thru. Ever hear of FavTrip? This 11-store operator out of Missouri has been successfully executing drive-thru service (and delivery and curbside pickup) for more than four years. And owner Babir Sultan has some advice for those considering designing one into their operation.

Drive-Thru Advice

As for all the talk Sultan knows is happening in the industry around drive-thru, his advice for operators thinking of adding a drive-thru is to make sure they clearly understand the potential pitfalls. “Don’t just add it because of COVID,” he said. It can actually create chaos, as store parking may already be tight, leaving customers to park in the drive-thru lane. He faced that issue when he first added drive-thrus. “It took a while to build customer awareness of it,” he said. “You don’t want to mess up the customer experience.”

Curbside pickup, as well as drive-thrus, may significantly change the design of c-stores down the road.

At FavTrip, the experience includes options for curbside pickup, delivery or drive-thru at all three FavTrip-branded stores; the additional nine stores Sultan owns operate under different gasoline brands. Most delivery orders start on the FavTrip website, where customers can order anything, including alcohol and tobacco.

“Everyone is a lot more focused on essential items now,” said Sultan of his customers’ preferences today. As a result, he has changed his product mix to include more frozen grocery products and teamed up with a fresh produce company to deliver fresh produce seven days a week. “You have to adapt to change; we shifted spacing to accommodate more household essential items.”

Sultan’s other piece of drive-thru advice is for operators to consider restaurant-type technology intended for a drive-thru experience. He’s looking at register technology compatible with drive-thrus and notes there are limitations integrating this technology with legacy gasoline station technology. His preference is more of the Chick-fil-A model, where staff can be found outside on tablets taking orders.

By the way, his stores currently don’t sell hot food, which was a problem when it came to partnering with a third-party delivery operation. The drive-thru is plenty successful without hot food, although he does plan to add it—likely pizza—when his new 4,000-square-foot ground-up store is complete mid-next year (his current stores average between 900 and 1,200 square feet). Notably, COVID-19 has slowed progress with the new site as the city moves at a slow pace at the moment for things like permits.

“Drive-thrus at c-stores are not expected,” confirmed Mike Lawshe, president of Paragon Solutions, a consulting, design and branding services firm headquartered in Fort Worth, Texas. “You have to educate and work with your customer.” He cited one example of a retailer with drive-thru sales of 5% pre-pandemic, that saw drive-thru sales reach 30% when the pandemic hit.

Drive-thrus, combined with pickup and delivery, are among the three most talked-about things since the pandemic, Lawshe noted. “The flow and functionality of design has changed forever.”

A Designer’s View of the New Normal

“I await with great interest to see how our industry reacts and moves forward post-COVID,” said Joe Bona, president of Bona Design Lab, a retail design firm based in Franklin, Massachusetts. While we all wait for the post-COVID-19 era to begin, he offered his take on a few considerations related to store design:

  • Designated floor markings: Tape on the floors gives way to better designed and more open layouts and may have a positive net effect on inside sales.
  • Forced flow layout: That was actually an old idea that was created several years ago that had a high degree of success in how we were able to get more customers past high-margin food and beverage categories. It resulted in a higher percentage of customers purchasing food and beverage items. In thinking about social distancing, it occurred to me that what is old may be new again, and this type of approach to layout may be a more effective way to provide a more organized flow of customers through the space and place greater emphasis on enhanced food programs.
  • Seating spaces: Seating was added to help build credibility for expanded food programs. As social distancing and closed-off in-store dining areas have become today’s new normal, less seating capacity might be the end result, with wider aisles and more open vistas that enhance the overall experience while providing a sense of public safety.
  • Drive-thrus and more: We have recently read how Wegmans grocery stores have eliminated their in-store, white tablecloth restaurants—never to reopen—to better expand their delivery service, curbside and in-store pickup due to consumer demands. And the likes of Wawa and other convenience stores have begun exploring drive-thru-only locations as a result of new consumer behavior, while others are rapidly advancing technology applications to provide contactless in-store interactions.
  • Future-forward design: Several of our clients are challenging us to help plan layouts and environments that consider the current crisis. We are working to come up with new designs that address many of these areas in anticipation that when life does return to normal, the stores we design will be relevant, customer focused and forward thinking, while also providing a sense of place where customers feel welcome, safe and secure with their purchases, however they are made.
Renee Pas

Renee Pas

Renee Pas’ writing draws from both her c-store background and her more than 20 years writing about various retail channels. She can be reached at [email protected].

Share:
Print:
To provide complete functionality, this web site needs your explicit consent to store browser cookies. We recommended that you "allow all cookies" so you may be able to use certain features, such as logging in, saving articles, or personalizing content.